Showing posts with label Mystery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mystery. Show all posts

Thursday, May 14, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 23


Arrow
Episode Title: “My Name is Oliver Queen”
Channel: CW
Director: John Behring
Writers: Marc Guggenheim and Jake Coburn
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: May 13, 2015

It's no secret that season three of Arrow has fallen short of the promise the show presented the audience in season two. Much of the season felt aimless, with the main villain appearing halfway through the season following a mostly pointless investigation into the murder of Sara. Although there were flashes of the quality we had become accustomed to it didn't feel like the show had the same fire. Now we're wrapping up the season with an episode that served to remind everyone of all the good and the bad we've seen so far.

I'm going to start off with the flashbacks. They have been lackluster all season, with nearly every one of them revolving around the capture of one fluid filled tube or another. After last week, with Akio dead and the ruin of the Yamashiros' marriage coming to light, it was hard to imagine what the point of this week's flashbacks would be. Oliver, Maseo, and Tatsu skirmished with General Shrieve's men and captured the general. They then left to have Akio's body cremated and Tatsu distributed the ashes in three urns to each of them. Oliver returned to Shrieve and tortured him, fully embracing the darkness that Amanda Waller had seen in him. He left Shrieve on death's door, and Maseo put the general out of his misery. Then, during the good bye sequence, Maseo fled his responsibilities as a husband. Tatsu decided to go to a monastery near her childhood home. Oliver made reference to keeping the darkness he had found in himself away from his family in Starling City, leaving us to believe that he intends to return to Lian Yu. There were no big reveals here, we already knew where these characters would end up. This season's flashbacks could have been condensed into half of the number of episodes they were featured in.

In present day, Oliver and Ra's were riding in an airplane towards Starling City. The plan began to experience malfunctions and Oliver revealed that it was all a sham to Ra's. Ollie then tossed a blade to Nyssa and they went on to take out the League men. Ra's was one step ahead of them though, grabbed the plane's only parachute and jumped out with the Alpha/Omega bioweapon. Luckily for Oliver and Nyssa, Oliver is apparently capable of emergency landing a cargo plane. They then set out to stop Ra's before he can release the weapon on the unsuspecting citizens of Starling City.

Back at Nanda Parbat we learn the fate of team Arrow. It wasn't some sort of knock out gas in the tube that the team was exposed to. It was the actual virus, luckily Merlyn had someone synthesize a vaccine. He administered it to the team through skin contact. That does leave the question though, how did the team know to fall unconscious to keep the ruse alive? Does the vaccine make the Alpha/Omega a relatively harmless sleeping gas? Whatever the explanation the team is still stuck in the dungeon. Until the Flash shows up to take out all the guards and release the team from captivity. This served to highlight one of the complications in a shared universe. The Flash has time for a quick jail break, but doesn't have the time to help Oliver end the threat to a major metropolis? It probably would have been better if the Flash had been left out of the episode altogether, at least then those type of question would have remained in the viewers' subconscious. As it was presented you couldn't help but wonder why Barry couldn't take a half hour to save the day.

The team got back to Starling City with no problems. (Where is Nanda Parbat anyway? You have to take a plane from there to Starling City, but if team Arrow took their plane how long did Ra's wait to put his plan into motion?) Merlyn started giving everyone on the team orders that they reluctantly followed and then Oliver showed up. Felicity, after some initial anger, seemed ready to forgive Oliver for the deception he had put them all through. Diggle was not as agreeable. He agreed to help only to save innocent civilians, his relationship with Oliver is very much a question mark now. After come computer based voodoo Felicity managed to track down the four places Ra's was preparing to release the virus. There was a tiny side-excursion by Oliver to a man named Damian Darhk, who is Ra's nemesis and a threat to the Demon Head's right to rule the League of Assassins. This bit was only filler, and a way to keep that name in the forefront of the audience's minds, presumably because Darhk will be a major player in season four. Another side-arc revolved around Laurel's attempt to get her father to help them track down the virus. Lance is drinking again, but that really could have waited until next season before coming to light

The team goes out to stop the bioweapon's release and discovers that Ra's plan was to infect four of his men and then have them spill their own blood to release the contagion. One of the walking virus bombs managed to complete his task after being shot by Thea, who is now gallivanting about in Roy's old costume. The birth of Speedy! A League member approached Oliver and invited him to watch Starling City at Ra's' side. Just like that it was time for the final showdown. This particular fight lacked the sense of dread that their previous encounter and been steeped in. While they were fighting Lance appeared at a post manned by some of the police force, who were being ordered to take out Ra's and Oliver. Before they could carry out their orders, Oliver beat Ra's, and in a poignant moment recited the same prayer Ra's has used upon vanquishing a foe.

Ray Palmer was busy during all of this, trying to figure out a way to stop the Alpha/Omega. While he and Felicity were brainstorming ideas they received a call from Captain Lance, sharing with them the amount of danger Oliver was in. Felicity implored Ray to don the ATOM suit and save Oliver, but he was having none of it; weighing Oliver's life against the thousands that could die if he didn't finish his work. When Oliver was shot he fell over the side of the Starling City Dam, but was saved from being splattered below by the ATOM. The television version of the ATOM's transformation into a discount Iron Man is now complete, after Oliver finds out that his savior is none other than Pepper Pots...I mean Felicity.

In the falling action a lot of story lines were set up for season four. Oliver and Felicity are going to run away together, with Oliver maintaining only his real identity. Before they left Oliver gave everyone a pep talk, telling them how certain he was that the rest of the team would manage well in his absence. He welcomed Thea into the fold and asked Diggle to keep fighting the good fight. Diggle is still not 100% on board, but if he continues his career as a vigilante Oliver suggested he find a way to obscure his identity. In the one big shocker of the finale Oliver is forced to pay the price for Malcolm Merlyn's help, that little bit of finger jewelry that serves as Ra's al Ghul's symbol of office is now in Merlyn's possession. This gives him control of the League, but Oliver reminded him that there were stipulations concerning how the League was to be run. I'm sure Merlyn will hold to his agreement for as short a time as possible. I hope that next season we see Merlyn OR Darhk as the villain, in my eyes both would be too much. The episode closed with Oliver and Felicity driving off to happier times, with Oliver admitting that he was finally happy. The ending was completely different from the finales of the previous two seasons, giving it a strange feel. It is as if the ending was thrown together in preparation for the show being canceled, finally giving Oliver a chance at a real life. Since there's not much of a show without Oliver Queen doing his thing it seems like a safe bet that something is going to ruin his happily ever after before the first commercial break of next season's premiere.

Conclusion: A happy ending to the season was not what I was expecting. On the whole “My Name is Oliver Queen” encapsulated much of what didn't work in season three. Although it had its positive moments, large chunks of the story simply fell flat. The evolution of Thea into masked crime fighter and Merlyn's new position were the best things to come out of the episode.

Rating: 6.5/10

Wednesday, May 6, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 22


Arrow
Episode Title: “This Is Your Sword”
Channel: CW
Director: Wendy Stanzler
Writers: Ben Sokolowski and Brian Ford Sullivan
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: May 6, 2015

“This Is Your Sword” is the next to last episode of this season of Arrow and it's too bad that it took so long to get to this point. The past few weeks have been some of the strongest episodes of the season, and this was no exception. It'll be pretty much impossible to talk about this week's Arrow without spoilers, so be warned.

Diggle, Laurel, and Felicity have gone back to crime fighting in Starling City, having accepted that Oliver is gone. The episode opened with Diggle giving chase to a random perp, who led him to an enclosed area with the rest of his gang waiting. Things look bad for a moment before Laurel makes an appearance with the Canary Cry. I really wish there was another way for them to convey that power on the screen; while it might work on the page it just looks ridiculous on television. Diggle lost it on the last guy and beat him to a pulp. Back at Diggle's, after an awkward attempt at a humorous moment regarding Laurel sneaking in the back to avoid questions from the neighbors, Diggle blew up in anger over Oliver's betrayal.

Back at Nanda Parbat Oliver and Ra's are seen discussing the next part of Oliver's ascension, his marriage to Nyssa and the destruction of Starling City. Oliver left to get some air, and met up with Malcolm for a clandestine meeting. Oliver dropped the facade and revealed that he's thought he'd have more time to bring the League down from the inside, but Ra's is forcing his hand. He and Malcolm hatch a plan to enlist the help of his former friends, and Malcolm departed just before Maseo showed up.

Felicity went to visit Ray again, and it's getting incrementally harder to like her character. She shows up to mope to him for a while, knowing that his feelings for her will keep him from sending her away. He had her sign a document, that is shown to be some sort of transfer of ownership papers. The audience is supposed to believe that the transfer is to Felicity, and while that seems probable I think a swerve might be in store; with Oliver regaining control of his company. Felicity received a text from Malcolm asking for a meeting and surprisingly she went.

The entire team showed up for the meeting with Malcolm, and of course he couldn't convince them of Oliver's plans, because Oliver had been too successful in convincing everyone of his turn. Malcolm breaks out his secret weapon, and it's Tatsu. I'm happy to see Tatsu joining the fray, but I was a little unclear on how her presence suddenly convinced the team to go back to Nanda Parbat. The script was really lacking in that regard, but the action is in Nanda Parbat, so if the team needs to get back there I guess any excuse, no matter how nebulous, is a good one. Tatsu also took a moment to share with Felicity how often Oliver spoke of her during his recovery.

Thea has gone off in search of Roy, who is working as a mechanic under the assumed name Jason. She managed to track him down with little effort and they had a quick reunion. They go back to his place and she presents him with his old vigilante costume, thinking that he could get back to what made him feel alive. She spent the night, but awoke in an empty bed. When she went to his place of employment she was told that he quit and took off, leaving a note for her. I don't know how sudden Colton Haynes decision to leave the show was, but I wish there had been a better way to handle his exit. His final words to Thea didn't really seem like a good way to end things, but he did leave his costume for her, so we'll be seeing Speedy in the near future.

The flashbacks this week were more of the same, A Quest for A Vial. Akio has fallen ill and Maseo and Oliver go to General Shrieve's hideout to get a cure. A cure that they have no proof of, they assume he'll have it anyway. After breaking in they briefly tortured Shrieve and he told them the cure was in a safe. They get it an bring him back to Akio to administer the cure. Akio is already dead and the cure was a rouse. He just wanted them to lead his men to their hiding place so he wouldn't have to hunt them down. It's important to remember that the vials didn't contain what we thought they did.

Another confrontation at Nanda Parbat! Merlyn, Diggle, Laurel, and Felicity team up with Tatsu, who is now in her costume as Katana, to storm the fortress. Felicity tried to hack into the airplane the League is going to use to spread the virus, but she is unsuccessful. Most of the action in this scene is pretty good, but the League of Assassins is more like a collection of Imperial Stormtroopers. At one point Laurel fights three of them at the same time. I'm all right with her taking down street criminals at this point, but there is no explanation for her ability to engage three of the supposed best killers in the world. When the airplane took off all appeared lost until Ray Palmer showed up and managed to bring the plane down. The highlight of this entire sequence was the duel between Tatsu and Maseo. The fight choreography and the final words between them were spot on, and easily one of the more emotional moments of the season. The League overcame its Stormtrooper-itis when reinforcements and Oliver showed up. The entire group was captured Malcolm tried in vain to reveal Oliver's duplicity, but it didn't seem like Ra's bought it. Ra's must have decided that it wasn't necessary to destroy Starling City, the friends of the former Oliver Queen would be good enough, and he broke the vial of Alpha/Omega in their holding cell. The marriage of Al Sah-Him to Nyssa was intercut with shots of Olivers friends apparently dying. I usually don't reference the previews for the next episode, and honestly the trickery out of General Shrieve should have been enough foreshadowing to convince the viewers that none of the rescue squad was in danger, but couldn't the previews be cut in such a way that the tension wasn't immediately sucked out of the end of the episode?

Conclusion: Despite the fact that some of the motivations were quite muddy, with the script doing no one any favors, “This Is Your Sword” finally got this season to where it should have been episodes ago. The action was high quality, and the Maseo/Tatsu drama was some of the best stuff of the season. We all suspected Oliver had bigger plans, now we just have to find out if those plans cost him the friends he's made along the way.

Rating: 8/10

Thursday, April 30, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 21


Arrow
Episode Title: “Al Sah-Him”
Channel: CW
Director: Thor Freudental
Writers: Brian Ford Sullivan and Emilio Ortega Aldrich
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: April 29, 2015

This week on Arrow we heard a new intro voice over from Stephen Amell, proclaiming that he was Oliver Queen. What followed was a montage of his training at the hands of Ra's. We're supposed to believe that he was broken down and brain washed into following Ra's orders without question. There just wasn't enough in the montage to give me the feeling that such a thing had happened over the course of the three weeks he'd been there. Even with the herb they've been giving him making him think he'd killed Diggle I didn't really get the feeling that Oliver had gone to the dark side. After three weeks of training Oliver was ready to go out and do Ra's' bidding, and he was sent out to deal with Nyssa, who is apparently a threat to his heir-ship (Heir-ness? Heirity?). This sets “Al Sah-Him” up as a villain of the week episode, with Oliver as the villain.

The rest of team Arrow is learning how to do things in Oliver's absence, again. Nyssa is still training Laurel, and we saw that the training isn't coming along very quickly as Nyssa had to step in and keep Laurel from getting hurt. This is important to a gripe I have regarding a moment later in the episode. Then they went to a diner for food, which was actually a good scene. Seeing Nyssa act more like a human was important because otherwise we wouldn't really care that she was Oliver's target. After Laurel told her that Oliver had accepted Ra's' offer Nyssa realized her time was short and went out to meet the threat headed her way. Diggle carried the load for the rest of the team, doing his best to pull them together during such a trying time. When Laurel told the team that Oliver would be coming for Nyssa they decided to face him and see if they could talk some sense into them.

The confrontation didn't go well for Nyssa. She was quickly subdued by Oliver and only saved when Diggle and Laurel made an appearance. We got our first look at Laurel's 'Canary Cry' and it was a underwhelming to say the least. Laurel looked as if she was screaming, but the sound coming out barely resembled a voice at all, which made her look a trifle silly standing there with her mouth hanging open. Oliver fled the scene and realized that now the team would be protecting Nyssa so he'd need to draw her out. What better way to get them to do what he wants than to kidnap and threaten Lyla? Diggle did the predictable thing and advocated turning Nyssa over to Oliver and the League.

Of course it was a swerve from Diggle and Co. Once Lyla was handed over they started an all out battle with Oliver and the League. During the rumble Laurel held her own for a period of time against two assassins, which is ridiculous after seeing her have trouble with a single mugger. The battle turned in Oliver's favor and he was prepared to strike a killing blow to Diggle when an arrow pierced his arm. The camera panned over to reveal Thea, in full vigilante regalia, with another arrow aimed at Ollie. She threatened to shoot him in the eye, and he retreated with Nyssa as his prize. There were moments each time we saw Oliver that make me think he's pulling a long con on the League. He gave up easily twice when confronted by his former friends and family, and if he's really wanted to get a reaction out of Diggle, little Sara would've made a far better incentive. Maybe it's wishful thinking, but I just can't see them making him the villain in his own show, no matter how briefly he may occupy that role.

The flashbacks this week were more of the same. Oliver, Maseo, and Tatsu doing their best to stop the release of the Alpha/Omega virus, and failing. In the last flashback sequence they're trying to get out of Hong Kong when Akio develops a nosebleed, signifying that we may finally see what drove the wedge between Maseo and Tatsu. The flashbacks this season have felt like there was enough content for half a season and it's been stretched to cover all twenty three episodes. At least the importance of the events in Hong Kon was finally made apparent when Ra's revealed the final part of Oliver's transformation.

When Oliver returned to Nanda Parbat, with Nyssa in tow, Ra's found the item Nyssa had stolen from him. The culmination of Oliver's metamorphosis into the Heir of the Demon is to be his destruction of Starling City. His tool for doing so is to be the stolen item, a vial of the Alpha/Omega virus. Ra's told Oliver to kill Nyssa, which he seemed willing to do, but Ra's stopped him at the last second to reveal his real plan. He intends for Oliver and Nyssa to marry and assume control of the League in his stead. Neither of the two seemed thrilled at the prospect of their union.

Conclusion: The flashbacks finally matter to the present day in a more important way than simply containing the Yamashiros, but they feel as if they were spread too thin over the course of the season. Seeing a cold-blooded and detached Oliver do whatever it takes to get to Nyssa was a fun concept, but I just can't shake the feeling that Oliver is still in there and waiting to make his move.

Rating: 7.75/10

Thursday, April 23, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 20


Arrow
Episode Title: “The Fallen”
Channel: CW
Director: Antonio Negret
Writers: Wendy Mericle and Oscar Balderrama
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: April 22, 2015

“The Fallen” was a drama heavy episode. Ra's has finally forced Oliver's hand, and with Thea's life hanging in the balance he had no other choice than to accept Ra's offer and become the Heir to the Demon. Throughout the entire episode Stephen Amell shined, conveying his grief over Thea's circumstances and leaving his friends behind, and the resigned acceptance of his place in Ra's plans. He was asked to carry the majority of the episode, and succeeded.

In an episode filled with powerful scenes the audience was treated to a good one very quickly. With Thea stabilized, but likely to never awake, Oliver was at her bedside when Malcolm came in. The devastated look on his face was a perfect moment from John Barrowman. His sorrow helped humanize a character that has become easy to dislike over the course of the show. After Maseo revealed to Oliver that there was still a way to save Thea's life, by accepting Ra's offer and joining the League, Malcolm argued against it. He claimed that the Thea that emerged from the Lazarus Pit would not be the one that she had been in life. His prediction proved briefly correct as she attacked Oliver and had severe gaps in her memory, but seems to have returned to normal after her initial confusion. This was a bit disappointing and I hope in coming episodes we are treated to more side effects of her resurrection.

Both Maseo and Ra's were the recipients of important character moments. One of the best scenes in the episode occurred between Maseo and Diggle. With Diggle accusing Maseo of cowardice, Maseo finally revealed what we all had presumed to be the case, Akio, his son is dead. That conversation would prove to be very important later on in the episode. Ra's himself was the focus a good piece of dialogue between himself and Felicity. He explained how he had come to be who and where he was an encouraged her to do something that had been impossible for him to do and tell someone she loves how much he means to her. This wasn't just a great scene because of the background information the audience got regarding Ra's, but it also served as one of Felicity's better moments this season.

Really Felicity was good this whole episode, which isn't something that can be said for her character much this season. She told Ray Palmer and Oliver how she really felt about her romantic entanglements, did her best to verbally confront the Demon himself, and when it looked like everything was lost formulated half of a plan to get Oliver out of Nanda Parbat. Even if that plan didn't go the way she wanted it was good to see her do more than flip flop her stances on things and follow others around. During her failed rescue attempt Maseo showed up trying to help, showing the audience that maybe the good man Oliver knew is still in there somewhere.

At the end it was all for naught, there's just no way for Oliver to break his commitment to the League. Although it seems like team Arrow has to say goodbye to each other far too often; this week's round of goodbyes was pretty touching. Oliver told Diggle how highly he thought of him, and once again had to leave Felicity teary-eyed and convinced that she'll never see him again. The whole scene was handled well and featured quality performances from everyone involved.

As has been the case for this entire season, the flashbacks were rather lackluster. This week they were used to inject some action into what was a drama heavy episode. The chase involving the cargo truck was fun, although I'm not sure how the team missed that transfer of the bio-weapon to the food cart. It was a little ridiculous that the vial Oliver and company were after was robust enough to survive the fight between Oliver and the street vendor, but shattered on the ground. They were hitting each other with the fist holding the vial, it simply broke when it could conveniently add to the tension in the scene. With failure apparent in the flashbacks it's hard to say where they go from here.

Conclusion: Having been placed in a situation he could no longer avoid, Oliver was forced to assume the role of Heir to the Demon. The character interplay in the present day scenes helped to keep the action-lite episode engaging. Now if only the flashbacks could be so successful.

Rating: 8/10

Thursday, April 16, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 19


Arrow
Episode Title: “Broken Arrow”
Channel: CW
Director: Doug Aarniokoski
Writers: Ben Sokolowski and Brian Ford Sullivan
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: April 15, 2015

Beware of Spoilers.

In “Broken Arrow” Oliver has been neutralized by the scrutiny Capt. Lance has leveled in his direction. Aside from harassing Oliver in the Arrow Cave and at his and Thea's home, he's making life for Oliver very difficult by keeping a very close eye on him. Lance knows Roy isn't the Arrow, but he can't prove it, so he's waiting for Oliver to slip. As if being unable to fulfill his quest to deal with crime in his city Oliver found himself at the mercy of those around him. They did a great job of conveying Oliver's feeling of helplessness in the face of a metahuman threat robbing banks in Starling City.

Oliver's inability to suit up and go catch the bad guy led to Ray Palmer entering the fray in the ATOM suit. There were some humorous moments involving Ray and Felicity's interactions with the rest of the team. Ray's first encounter with the metahuman goes very badly for him and when he returned to the team's backup control center Oliver gave him a pretty uplifting pep talk. I was a little disappointed that instead of learning his way and getting into a better mindset for the job Ray's second encounter with the villain involved him putting on the suit and ceding complete control to Oliver. I think it would have been more effective to have him achieve victory on his own, but I guess they had to keep the Arrow involved in the action somehow.

The conflict this week was two fold. On one hand we've got Roy. After confessing to being the Arrow he's in serious trouble in prison. Colton Haynes really shined this week. In what has to be one of the best action sequences of the season we got to watch a handcuffed Roy take out several fellow inmates. His arc very smoothly shifted gears after that with Thea's visit to prison. It was an emotional scene that seemed to foreshadow something big coming for the character, although I didn't anticipate it happening so soon. Another attack on Roy left him dead, in anticlimactic fashion, and it was revealed quickly that Lyla's contacts in ARGUS allowed the team to fake Roy's death and get him out of prison. Oliver's guilt over the situation before he learned the truth was one of Amell's better acting moments in the series so far. With Roy dead in every legal sense he left Starling City to start anew. The send off could have used a little something more, but overall it played out pretty well.

Lest we forget about Ra's and his plan to force Oliver to accept the mantle of the Demon's Head, Ra's popped up at the end of the episode to confront Thea. She tried to go toe to toe with him, with predictable results. When it was all said and done the leader of the League of Assassins had stabbed Thea and left her for dead. Clearly it was an attempt to force Oliver to accept his offer and take his place, surely with the promise of a Lazarus Pit capable of saving Thea's life as a major bargaining chip. It appears that Ra's has backed Oliver into a corner with little choice but to accept his new role.

Other odds and ends in the episode: the Hong Kong flashbacks improved somewhat this week. It at least appears that there something for the last few episodes to work towards on that front, even though even in her present condition I don't trust Amanda Waller at all, especially after Diggle revealed that ARGUS has in its employ a man that specializes in stabbing people in such a way that they bleed a lot but survive. The writers did a good job this week of incorporating almost everyone in the cast. Besides the tension relieving presence of Ray and Felicity, Diggle and obviously Roy got moments to shine, with the sole overlooked character being Laurel, who was only in the episode briefly. The final scene involving Ray and Cisco at S.T.A.R. Labs metahuman prison was good for some laughs, and revealed very important information. Apparently there is something else out there causing metas to pop up, meaning we may be seeing more super-powered villains in Arrow.

Conclusion: Ra's plan has reached a new level of insidious and there doesn't seem to be any way out of the situation for Oliver. It was interesting seeing Oliver nearly powerless to act in such a dire situation, hopefully pointing to better integration of the supporting characters into his plans going forward. It's hard being too concerned for Thea's well being, if nor no other reason than the show already relieved itself of Roy and I can't imagine them shedding two characters in the same episdoe.

Rating: 8/10

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 18


Arrow
Episode Title: “Public Enemy”
Channel: CW
Director: Dwight Little
Writers: Marc Guggenheim and Wendy Mericle
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: April 1, 2015

“Public Enemy” occupied both ends of the spectrum that Arrow has managed to occupy this season. When things are good they're still really good. But when something isn't working it's almost hard to watch. Lets start with the big reveal from two weeks ago, in the flashbacks Oliver has run into Shado! Only it's not Shado it's her twin sister, Mei. It didn't signify a change in direction for the Hong Kong flashbacks. Oliver and Akio are still fleeing ARGUS's men, and Mei allowed them to take refuge in her home. She is understandably perplexed by the American that seems to know her sister and when no answers are forthcoming she calls the police. Of course the police don't show up, an ARGUS goon squad does instead. Luckily for Oliver and Akio, the Yamashiros pick that moment to pick up their trailer and fight the goons off. They decide to leave, and on the way out Oliver tells Mei that her sister and father are dead. She's grateful to him for finally delivering the truth, the reunited Yamashiros and Oliver leave her in a destroyed house. How many more weeks can the flashbacks consist solely of running from ARGUS? After how well the flashbacks of the first two seasons complimented the present day story this season has been a major disappointment in that arena.

Back in the present day things are getting really bad for team Arrow. After Maseo's hit on the mayor, Captain Lance has mobilized the entire police department in an attempt to capture the Arrow. The team believed they had tracked down the League's safe house, and after a brief fight during which, surprise surprise, both Laurel and Roy held their own, Ra's showed himself. He gave Oliver another chance to assume leadership of the League, and upon being refused again revealed that the authorities were on their way. The team's desperate flight from the scene was one of the highlights of the episode, and despite a couple of wrinkles they all managed to get away. Later on Lance was captured by the League and had a face to face meeting with Ra's, who revealed the Arrow's secret identity. Armed with his new information Lance redoubled his efforts to catch Oliver Queen.

In the attack on the mayor's office Ray Palmer was severely injured. He has a clot that could cause a stroke, but the surgery to remove it is very likely to kill him. He has his nano-tech back at his lab that could solve the problem, but the doctor won't allow it. Surprising no one, Felicity brought the nano-tech to him anyway and Ray was cured. What followed was a bit of soap opera that felt like another show entirely. Ray confessed his love and Felicity ran away. Her mother stops her and muddied the waters further by extolling the virtues of both of the men in Felicity's life. These scenes all felt out of place in the rest of the episode. I think it would have been better if there had been a few Palmer-centric episodes, and not this awkward attempt to have him in every episode. With the desperate straits team Arrow is dealing with the Ray/Felicity material just doesn't feel right.

Oliver, faced with no where to run made a decision regarding his next move. I'm not sure if Ra's' plan was to force Oliver to accept his offer, with no where else to run, or to see Oliver captured. Clarification in that regard would have helped the audience know whether to be excited that Oliver had outwitted the Demon's Head or to despair because he'd been driven right where he was wanted. Oliver has apparently confessed everything to Lance and the Starling City Police in return for immunity for the rest of his team. The team of course is unwilling to let things go that way. We saw Lance and Oliver riding in the back of a police van, and having an intense discussion regarding Lance's feelings towards Oliver and all the lies that have been told. Paul Blackthorne really brought it in this scene, sadness and anger alternating on his face. There's a thump on the roof of the vehicle and it stops. Lance got out of the van in time to see a man in the Arrow costume jump down and confess his identity. Roy then pulled the hood from his face, to the surprise of everyone, especially Oliver. This scene was a little problematic, Lance knows Roy isn't the Arrow, he's even called him out on his identity while wearing the Arsenal get-up. Somehow the audience is supposed to believe that this ruse is going to work, but the writers of the next episode are going to have a hard time convincing us of that.

Conclusion: Ra's al Ghul's plan seems to finally be coming to fruition. Oliver is left with very few options as the manhunt for the Arrow finally nabs him. Although the season has finally gotten to a point that feels as dire as last season's Slade Wilson arc the build up has been far less interesting. I feel like the Ray and Felicity content would be better off contained to a few episodes instead of so drastically altering the tone of each episode. The flashbacks have got to improve, it seems like they've been spinning their wheels for weeks.

Rating: 7.75/10

Wednesday, March 25, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 17


Arrow
Episode Title: “Suicidal Tendencies”
Channel: CW
Director: Jesse Warn
Writer: Keto Shimizu
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: March 25, 2015

“Suicidal Tendencies” began with Diggle and Lyla getting married. Shortly after the ceremony the members of team Arrow are all notified via their phones of a new Arrow story, the press is running with the “The Arrow is killing folks again” con being fed to them by Ra's. Diggle offers to stay and help Oliver look into the allegations, but is told to go ahead with his honeymoon. Before he and Lyla can even get to the airport they're brought into a hostage rescue mission by Floyd Lawton and ARGUS. So instead of Fiji, Diggle and Lyla team up with Deadshot and Cupid and are inserted into the country of Kasnia to retrieve a bunch of hostages that include a U.S. Senator.

Aside from Slade Wilson, Deadshot has been one of the better villains this show has managed to set up. So I was glad to see him pop back up. Not only did he play a major part in the Diggle and Lyla portions of the show but through him we also received a reprieve from the Hong Kong flashbacks; which had reached a new level of boring last week. Although there weren't many of them, this week the flashbacks focused on Lawton's return from war and his inability to rejoin peaceful, law-abiding citizens. The scene when he just loses it on his wife and daughter was hard to watch, you could see that he just doesn't get normal life anymore. Lawton had turned himself into something that can't exist outside of the battlefield, which he proved by accepting the contract that was offered to him, on Diggle's brother.

Back in Kasnia things really fall apart for the Suicide Squad when everything is revealed to be a set up by the senator. He thought that he would somehow increase his chances of being elected President by surviving a kidnapping at the hands of terrorists. When the squad showed up to rescue him he dropped the facade, claimed that the other hostages were no witnesses to his duplicity and had his men wire the building to explode. Following a shoot out, and a conversation between Diggle and Lyla that is overheard by Deadshot, talking about getting home to their daughter, Lawton and the rest of the team concoct a way to free the hostages and get everyone out safely. Everyone but Deadshot, who apparently sacrifices himself so the rest can get away. There's no way I believe he's dead, he's one of only a few quality villain-esque characters the show has set up, so I expect to see him again. No body, no death. It's also worth noting that Cupid wasn't quite as irritating this time around as in her introduction episode. She's still taking crazy to the next level, but it wasn't quite as grating.

Back in Starling City the police are initiating a manhunt for the Arrow, aided by Ray Palmer. Ray tracked the Arrow to the next location Ra's and his men attacked, conveniently showing up only as the League's men have departed and Oliver is left standing amidst the bodies of their victims. Ray used the x-ray vision in his suit and a facial recognition program that Felicity wrote to identify the Arrow as Oliver and tried to go to the police with the knowledge. Instead he ended up sitting across from Laurel, who does her best to dissuade him from pursuing what he thinks he knows. Instead he faked a 911 call and lured Arrow and Roy to an isolated spot. Once again Roy is swatted aside in a fraction of a second and the showdown really begins. As an aside, Roy isn't my favorite character, but even I'm getting sick of the exercise in futility nearly every one of his fights turns into. Throw the guy a bone and let him shine in a fight or two before he is once again humiliatingly bested. Moving on, Oliver and Ray spar for a couple of minutes before Oliver notices some sort of Death Star-like weakness in the ATOM suit's design. With one well placed dart throw Oliver shuts down the suit, and then talks Ray into believing him. Ray might want to put some shielding on that thermal exhaust port.

There were a couple of issues I had with the episode. First I'm just not buying Captain Lance's now complete hatred of the Arrow. I know he feels like the Arrow conspired to hide his daughter's death from him, but he's also done a lot of good. They fought side by side against Slade's men, and cooperated to apprehend some dangerous people. His complete 180 on the subject just doesn't feel genuine. The other issue is something that has plagued this entire season, the writing of the Felicity Smoak character. This isn't about which romance she should be pursuing or if it should even be there. When you watch a show on the CW you know that every romantic angle is going to be presented at some point. My issue is with the constant inconsistencies in the way the character responds to situations. She has become the ultimate flip-flopper. First she defends Oliver tooth and nail in an argument with Palmer, than she accuses Oliver of wanting Ray dead and out of the way ten minutes later. I just doesn't make sense.

To wrap up the episode Ray and Oliver have come to an understanding and Palmer is pleading the Arrow's case to the city brass. Only minutes earlier in an obvious moment of foreshadowing Ollie mentioned to Diggle that he was most worried about when Ra's and his men tired of killing criminals and went after innocent people. During Ray's meeting with the Lances, Laurel and Quentin, and the mayor an arrow strikes the mayor, presumably killing her. Maseo is shown outside drawing back his bow to fire another arrow, this time aimed at Felicity and...fade to black. I'd been wondering when Maseo was going to be forced to do some of the dirty work and stop acting as a liaison between Ra's and Oliver. I don't think anyone believes that Felicity is in danger of dying, but an injury to Smoak could be the catalyst needed to spark a confrontation between Oliver and Maseo, and shed some light on how things went wrong back in Hong Kong. I think the flashbacks are going to be taking it up a few notches in the coming weeks.

Conclusion: “Suicidal Tendencies” had a lot going on, and although there were two separate stories being told neither felt like it got the short end in regards to time. After some initial conflict Oliver has gained a powerful ally, one whom I hope they bring a little closer to the source material. At this point Ray Palmer is a boring Tony Stark, with a glitchy suit. After seeming a bit rudderless in the early parts of the season it looks like everything is building to something pretty fun.

Rating: 8/10

Thursday, March 19, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 16


Arrow
Episode Title: “The Offer”
Channel: CW
Director: Dermott Downs
Writers: Beth Schwartz and Brian Ford Sullivan
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: March 18, 2015

It's been over a month since the audience saw Ra's make his offer to Oliver. For me “The Offer” was met with excitement and anticipation. Sure, we all knew Oliver was going to say no, but surely there would be consequences for his refusal. Ra's, I'd imagine, is not used to being denied and the wrath of a functionally immortal assassin must be terrible. Ra's instead allowed Oliver to take Diggle and Malcolm back home to Starling City as some sort of peace offering while Oliver reconsiders his answer. He also told Ollie that it was preordained that he'd take up the mantle of the Demon's Head, his city would turn against him, and that the resources of the League would allow him to do far more good than he has up to this point.

This lead to Oliver questioning what he's actually accomplished up to this point. When you consider; most of the guys he's gotten locked up were released a few episodes ago, Quentin Lance has decided to hold it against the Arrow that he knew of Sara's death, and that he walked in on Felicity and Ray 'having a moment,' it's not a whole lot. The threat of a new bad guy, Murmur, equipping himself and his thugs with diamond-tipped cop killing ammunition gets team Arrow into the field and offered a welcome respite from the pity party.

Oliver's not the only one. He stashed Malcolm at Thea's home while Merlyn recuperates. She spends most of the episode fantasizing about killing him, and realizing that she's probably a bad person because of that. At one point she lamented to Laurel that she can't even remember who she was before her mother died. She says this as if she were some upstanding citizen previously, which she most certainly wasn't. Back in Nanda Parbat, Nyssa is having her own problems understanding what Ra's is doing, offended that he would offer his title to an outsider. After she halfheartedly attacks him I understood him to say that if she didn't like it, go do something about it. I expected to see her trying to undermine the Arrow's working in Starling City, but instead she's befriending Laurel and offering to train her. I'm truly confused by that bit of the story.

To wrap up the episode the audience is shown a man in a costume identical to Oliver's shooting and killing a few thugs. The man tells the sole survivor to go and tell everyone what he saw. The camera panned around and we see Ra's in the costume. While it wasn't a total surprise that Ra's had a plan to make sure the city turned against him, it was a surprise to see him doing the dirty work himself. He seems like the kind of guy that would send an underling to do that kind of work, I think it would have made more sense to have Maseo doing the killing. Maybe Ra's is just bored and looking to get out of the house.

You'll probably notice that there's been no mention of the flashbacks. Over the last few weeks the flashbacks had been improving, but this week they were a waste of time. Oliver and Akio running through random spots trying to avoid goons. I suppose the lack of anything of substance was supposed to be redeemed by the one important thing to happen, “Shado! What are you doing here?” but the reveal seemed so cheap that it's certain to be a ploy. If it's not than a lot of the important events in the last two seasons are completely undermined.

Conclusion: This was not the way I expected Arrow to come back from its break. “The Offer” just lacked the big moments necessary for a mini-premiere. Half of the characters doubting their place in the world and what they stand for might work during a run of consecutive episodes, but it failed to deliver here. It was lackluster enough that I found myself thinking jokingly that it's time to use some of that shared universe mojo, show Starling City being affected by Barry Allen's jump back in time and lets get a do over.

Rating: 6.5/10

Wednesday, February 25, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 15


Arrow
Episode Title: “Nanda Parbat”
Channel: CW
Director: Gregory Smith
Writers: Erik Oleson and Ben Sokolowski
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: February 25, 2015

Arrow tried to go into a mini-break with the same kind of momentum that it went into the winter break with. The audience was left with a couple of cliffhangers, one of which will prove to be the driving force behind the remainder of the season. Unfortunately a lot of that was set into motion by characters doing stupid stuff.

First of all, after “Nanda Parbat” everyone knows everything. Laurel knows Thea killed Sara, Thea knows Roy killed a cop, Nyssa knows Thea is the one responsible for Sara's death, not Malcolm. The secrets and lies are off the table. This is actually a good thing, as the constant who knows what portions of this season had long since become tiresome. Laurel's not angry with Thea, instead she tries to confront Malcolm over his involvement in the whole mess. This led to a rather entertaining bit of 'action' in which Laurel manages to lose her weapon and fall down a lot. I was against Laurel becoming a vigilante so soon, but at this point her ineptitude is almost painful to watch. It's time to train her up so she isn't flailing about, more a danger to herself than the bad guys. Oliver managed to capture Nyssa during the leagues kidnapping of Malcolm, this serves two purposes. First, she reveals to Oliver where Nanda Parbat is located of her own free will, and it allows Thea to confess to Nyssa that she is the one that actually struck Sara down. Thea frees Nyssa and puts a sword in her hand, and the audience is left with a month of wondering what happens next.

Why did Oliver want to know where Nanda Parbat is, you ask? Well, he's of the opinion that Thea can't handle the stain on her soul that being responsible for her father's death would bring. So he's going to rescue Merlyn. Diggle goes with Ollie on the mission, with Diggle getting some much deserved action scenes. He really needs to be incorporated in the action stuff more, especially with Lyla reminding him that he can't just stop being a soldier. Aside from Oliver he's the most capable fighter they have, it makes little sense to keep him on the sidelines so often. They mow through a bunch of the League's men and make their way to Malcolm, who reveals, big surprise here, it's a trap! Oliver and Dig are captured, leading to a pretty touching moment when Diggle asks Oliver to be his best man. Eventually Oliver is brought before Ra's and it looks like Ra's is going to finish what he started in “The Climb.” Instead Ra's has decided that Oliver would be a good successor to his position in the League. Not sure I get the thinking behind that one, as Oliver has already proven himself not up to the task; but maybe they'll clear that up in the coming episodes.

There were some other things happening that deserve a mention. After Thea tells Roy everything (he knew it anyway) he takes her to the family of the cop he killed and tells her how he's trying to atone for what he did. It was a good moment for the character, and there have been few of those this season, so it was good to see a little time devoted to him. Ray Palmer and Felicity had their own scenes this week, which culminated in a little personal time for the two, after which Ray had a predictable epiphany that allowed him to complete the A.T.O.M. suit. We even got to see it in action, though I hope they reveal some of it's other features very soon, otherwise it's going to come off as an Iron Man clone. The flashbacks this week were relatively sparse, but action packed. Oliver and the Yamashiros are released from custody and told they can go home. They're attacked on the dock on the way to the ship that's to take them back to Japan. After a firefight Oliver and their son, Akio, are separated from Maseo and Tatsu, and Maseo tells them to run for it. I have a feeling we're close to finding out what happened that drove the wedge between the Yamashiros, and drove Maseo to the League.

Conclusion: This week's confrontation with Ra's al Ghul lacked the tension of “The Climb” but still managed to surprise at the end. I just hope they justify Ra's' interest in Oliver, as he doesn't seem like the kind of guy the Demon's Head would look to as an heir. With all the secrets in the open maybe we can see some growth in the relationships between various members of the growing Team Arrow. I was left wanting something more from the first Atom reveal, it felt like that could have been withheld until more time could be devoted to it.

Rating: 7.5/10

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 14


Arrow
Episode Title: “The Return”
Channel: CW
Director: Dermott Downs
Writers: Marc Guggenheim and Erik Oleson
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: February 18, 2015

What a strange week on Arrow. I didn't keep a stopwatch handy, but I'm pretty sure that the flashbacks this week accounted for more of the show's length than the present day stuff. Normally that wouldn't be an issue for me, the flashback components of this season have gotten steadily better as things have gone along. All of this week's flashbacks taking place in Starling City, with the present day story line happening on the island, was a nice juxtaposition. The issue I take with the management of time in “The Return” is that it deprived the audience of some real quality time with Slade Wilson.

I was very excited to see Manu Bennett reprise his role as Wilson. Wilson provided for season two what this season has lacked; a villain that the audience cared about. Unfortunately he's not around very long in “The Return.” There are a couple of face to face meetings with Oliver and Thea, and one good action sequence with a two on one fight; underutilized is the best way to describe his involvement in this one. Aside from the time spent on the island the only other scenes from present day involved Laurel and Det. Lance at Sara's grave. It seems that his acceptance of her admission is not going to go as smoothly as it appeared in “Canaries.” He's turned it into a trust/honesty issue and is threatening to start drinking again over it. Laurel talked him down but it's clear that their relationship is going to remain damaged for the foreseeable future.

The flashbacks this week featured Ollie back in Starling City doing Amanda Waller's bidding, stopping Chien Na Wei's sale of the Omega virus at auction. Although he and Maseo were eventually successful the real highlights of the flashbacks were Ollie's peripheral activities. He spent most of his time running around Starling City stalking his family and friends. It was fun to see Tommy Merlyn alive and breathing again, and Detective Lance in the aftermath of Sara's first death (As a side note, the wig they had on Paul Blackthorne looked much more believable than the one they've been putting on Stephen Amell) as a functional drunk. It seemed a little ridiculous that he also managed to cross paths with Felicity and Diggle, but somehow managed to avoid Moira completely. The one aspect of flashbacks (and prequels) I find irritating are the references to things that the audience knows that the characters don't. This week is was Maseo commenting that the hood Oliver was wearing wouldn't disguise him from anyone, “even if you smeared grease paint all over your face.” It's like all the bald jokes in the last two X-Men movies at Xavier's expense, they don't add much for me and I'd rather see them avoided.

The last thing of note occurred in the present day scenes. Oliver revealed to Thea that she is the one that killed Sara, she is understandably upset and takes it out on Malcolm when they return to Starling City. He genuinely seems hurt that she reacted in the way she did, and he definitely wasn't happy with Oliver for sharing that information. This moment seemed like the catalyst necessary for her sudden about-face regarding Merlyn, as her reaction this week didn't see justified at that point.

Conclusion: The flip flopping of the settings for the present day and flashbacks was a novel touch, but it couldn't mask the feeling that this was a place holder episode. The return of Slade Wilson was underwhelming and the constant glimpses of characters for whom the audience knows what the future holds got a little tiresome. The only things of real substance to occur were Thea's discovery of her role in Sara's death and her subsequent tirade directed at Malcolm and Quentin Lance's anger at the way Laurel had hidden Sara's death from him.

Rating: 6.5/10

Thursday, February 12, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 13


Arrow
Episode Title: “Canaries”
Channel: CW
Director: Michael Schultz
Writers: Jake Coburn and Emilio Ortega Aldrich
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: February 11, 2015

Count Vertigo returns to Starling City! Did he play a huge role in the episode? Well that can be debated. He was the driving force behind Laurel's story this week, but didn't do a whole lot otherwise. It's just good to see Peter Stormare back, the guy does zany, wild-eyed villain better than just about anyone else; it's always fun to see him on screen. While I'm still not entirely sold on the masked vigilante aspect of Laurel's character it's encouraging to see that she's not very good at it yet. If she was just crushing bad guys I'd be more uncomfortable with where her character is now, but I suppose if she's going to jump right into the fight this is the best way to do it. The doses of Vertigo that the Zytle hit her with forced her to confront a nightmare version of her sister; echoing back the insecurities that Laurel feels about her abilities and motivation. It seems like she's finally come to terms with the fact that she can't be Sara, but she can still do some good. The other side effect of her Vertigo-induced visions is that she's finally decided to break the news of Sara's death to her father. Naturally he was devastated and it's too soon to know if there will be repercussions for her hiding the truth for so long, but the sorrow Paul Blackthorne was able to show in that scene deserves a mention.

Oliver also had a big reveal to make in “Canaries,” he finally decided to come clean to Thea about his other life. I had feared that this revelation would result in a schism between them, a way for the writers to add more drama to the situation. I think that would have been one too many things going wrong for Oliver recently and I'm glad they decided to avoid that. Instead she takes it remarkably well, it erased the tension that had sometimes been between them so far in season three. Her abrupt change of heart regarding Malcolm though seemed a bit forced. Not long ago she was talking him out of killing and vowing that they would defend themselves against Ra's al Ghul as a family. She's back to thinking of him as nothing but an evil schemer, but she doesn't really know anything more or less about him than she did; so what's with the sudden change in her view of him?

There was a scene following Laurel's first dose of Vertigo where Ollie started barking orders at Thea to go away. Roy immediately stepped in and stood up to Oliver. I knew a moment like this was coming, but I hadn't expected it so soon. While the team is very happy Oliver isn't dead, they discovered while he was gone that they can operate without him. They had developed their own decision making process, something that was much more democratic. Although we see Ollie come to terms with the new dynamic I would wager that it will create some additional friction in the episodes to come.

The one really weak moment of the episode followed the shouting match mentioned above. Thea fled the club and ran into the DJ that's popped in and out of the season. If you remember it was revealed last week that he's actually an agent of the League of Assassins. I had hoped that the new information would make the character a little more important, and a lot more memorable since in all honesty I had to look up the character's name (Chase). Instead after some physical comfort Thea realizes he has bad intentions and they get into a brief fight. He bests her but before he can finish her off Roy bursts in. Now I'm not a huge Roy fan, most of the time he's just there, but he gets beat up again this week. In short order. I know this Chase fellow is an agent of the League, so it's to be expected that he can handle himself in a fight, but Roy barely lasts fifteen seconds against the guy. This is just the latest in a succession of martial failures for the character. Does anyone remember that it was apparently such a foregone conclusion that Cupid could defeat him that it didn't even happen on camera? Cut the guy some slack and let him win a fight or two! It's a good thing Merlyn showed up to bail him out.

The flashbacks this week centered around the Oliver and the Yamashiro's attempted flight from Hong Kong. Since Oliver still has two years away from Starling to account for we knew that he at least would be unsuccessful. In a surprising turn of events though the next mission that Amanda Waller has for Oliver involves his return to Starling City. We'll just have to wait until next week to see how she manages to keep him under wraps in a city that's presumably pretty used to seeing his face plastered on the tabloids. At the end of the episode Merlyn tells the Queens that the only way they can overcome Ra's is to conquer their fear, which for Ollie means a return to the Island. This will set up an intriguing new format for next week's episode; the present day scenes will occur on the island, and the flashbacks in Starling City.

Conclusion: I've been waiting for Oliver to reveal his secret to Thea, and was pleased with the way it was handled; even if the fallout is a strange reversal of her feeling towards Merlyn. Laurel is growing into the role of the Canary, and maybe if she stops trying to be her sister I'll buy her evolution a little more. The secret of Sara's death is finally out in the open with Detective Lance, and while it doesn't seem to have killed him as Laurel feared it would I'm left wondering if their teary embrace is only the calm before the storm. Finally, we're finally going back to the Island!

Rating: 7.75/10

Wednesday, February 4, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 12


Arrow
Episode Title: “Uprising”
Channel: CW
Director: Jesse Warn
Writers: Beth Schwartz and Brian Ford Sullivan
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: February 4, 2015

This week we were led to believe we'd witness an epic showdown between Team Arrow and Brick's minions. What we got was a lot of talking. The philosophical debate while mildly interesting didn't provide the drama that the previous two episodes had. It seems that since everyone had come to terms with Oliver's absence the characters all stalled out. Felicity was the most frustrating of the team's members, it was her words that allowed the team to take up Oliver's fight, but she's just incapable of doing what needed to be done. The compromises that needed to be made were beyond her.

The flashbacks this week revolved around Malcolm Merlyn and the time after his wife, Rebecca's, murder. It's clear that we're going to see some sort of redemption of the character in the near future, although the writers are going to have their work cut out for them. Making the audience forget the things he's done, and convincing us that the other characters have forgiven him for the his actions will be no small order. It was fun to see a more innocent Merlyn seeking vengeance and eventually making his way to the League of Assassins. The advent of his name, The Magician, was a nice touch. I hope we see more of his training, especially now that he's agreed to help Oliver train to fight Ra's Al Ghul. I can see a few moments when Ollie's training parallel's his own revealing to the audience more about how Merlyn became the man we know him as now.

Speaking of Oliver, I have mixed feelings about his return to Starling City. Clearly it was time for him to return, as his supporting characters seem to have gotten to a point where they can't maintain the same entertainment level that the previous two episodes have enjoyed. When the battle royale between Brick's men and Team Arrow's Glades militia began I expected it to go badly and for Oliver's return to turn the tide. Although it would have been a dramatic entry I think the way it was handled actually works better. Team Arrow was winning, proving that they're capable of operating with out the Arrow if necessary, even Laurel; which might help to avoid an awkward moment during which Oliver tells her she's not ready. He didn't swoop in and save his friends, he swooped in and saved his enemy from falling another notch towards unforgivable. Yes it's self-serving, Oliver needs Merlyn to train him, but it also highlights the major difference between the two. Malcolm would have watched the Arrow sink to his level, Oliver wants to redeem Merlyn. That simple truth will make the next few weeks interesting as we see whose desires take hold.

After praising Henry Allen's ability to pierce the secret identity of a hero on The Flash last night I'd be remiss in not mentioning that Det. Lance was also not to be fooled, He saw right through Roy's disguise and managed to throw some quips about it as well. Sin popped back into the picture as an ally in the Glades, and was around just long enough to tell Lance that she doesn't believe the current Canary is Sara. It's about time Laurel's lies in that regard were exposed, and it's sure to lead to fireworks when he finally finds proof or confronts Laurel over the matter. Can his health hold up and if so, can his relationship with his remaining daughter survive the truth?

Conclusion: The Brick story line didn't conclude with the bang I was expecting. It seems everyone but Diggle and Brick forgot about the guns they'd been toting. Oliver's return, while anticlimactic, was probably done in the best way possible; establishing that Team Arrow and all of it's members are capable of doing what must be done to save Starling City. The uneasy alliance with Malcolm Merlyn may still fracture the team, but it should lead to good television going forward.

Rating: 7/10

Thursday, January 29, 2015

Arrow: Season 3, Episode 11


Arrow
Episode Title: “Midnight City”
Channel: CW
Director: Nick Copus
Writers: Wendy Mericle and Ben Sokolowski
Genre: Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: January 28, 2015

This week's Arrow continued to chronicle the struggles of Team Arrow regarding their attempts to continue Oliver's work without him. The newest crime boss in Starling City, Brick, is making his play for power; this time kidnapping several city officials and threatening their lives if the police presence in the Glades isn't withdrawn. Meanwhile, Oliver is convalescing in a cabin tended to by Maseo and Tatsu.

The crisis in Starling City has reached new heights, the newest threat to the city has escalated quickly and it wasn't long before the remaining members of Oliver's team, along with Laurel as the Canary, decided to take action. I'm actually really liking the way the team is functioning without Oliver. Roy is becoming more comfortable with taking the lead in the field. Harper has been an underutilized character this season, so seeing him with something meaningful to do is an improvement. Laurel's first few appearances as the Canary have not gone well for her. I'm glad that she hasn't been thrown into the fight and shown that she's somehow become a fighter of the caliber of the rest of the team. Besides the physical abuse that she's received she was also confronted with the consequences of her failures. At the moment that she's at her lowest Felicity comes into play to remind her that although their mission comes with a huge price to pay it's something that has to be done. Diggle and Roy's moment over drinks after a long day served to show that everyone that Oliver has left behind are finally coming to grips with his absence.

The one major negative I saw in the scenes from Starling City involved Laurel's interactions with her father. I know that she's convinced that learning of Sara's death would kill her father, but the way in which she's deceiving him is sure to have dire ramifications going forward. When the ruse is is revealed it seems like it is going to do irreparable harm to their relationship. That's a moment that I'm dreading.

Thea has refused to flee Starling with Malcolm Merlyn; setting up and inevitable confrontation between them and Ra's al Ghul. A seemingly useless plot point from much earlier in the season finally showed some purpose when it was revealed that the new DJ at Verdant is at the very least a League of Assassin's informant, or possibly a member himself. Maseo's role in the current plans of the League is a little unclear but we've been led to believe that he's somehow spearheading the League's eventual confrontation with Merlyn. Between his actions regarding Oliver and his involvement with whatever is in store for Merlyn I found myself wondering; could he be setting Ra's up for a fight with Oliver and Merlyn fighting side by side. I think it's possible that whatever caused the separation between Maseo and Tatsu was the result of something Ra's did. Maseo's insistence that he return to the League may be the result of his desire for revenge. It's just a crazy theory, but you never know.

That brings us to Oliver and his recovery. The words “Lazarus Pit” haven't been uttered yet, to my disappointment. There's no other way to explain Oliver's recovery, I refuse to accept that some penicillin tea somehow saved him from his wounds and the elements. The flashbacks in this episode served to highlight the dramatic change in Maseo and Tatsu's relationship. While nothing notable was discovered this week during those flashback they have the feeling that they're setting the audience up for tragedy.

Conclusion: I actually could have done with less Oliver this week, as the more compelling moments of “Midnight City” revolved around his friends and the way they're coping/carrying on following his death. Laurel's blunders during her first forays as a vigilante are also managing to soften the disbelief I had feared would surround her shouldering of the Canary mantle.

Rating: 7.5/10