Showing posts with label Co-op. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Co-op. Show all posts

Thursday, March 19, 2015

Betrayal at House on the Hill


Betrayal at House on the Hill: 2nd Edition
Publisher: AvalonHill (2010)
Players: 3-6
Play Time: 30 min – 2 hrs
Genre: Board Game, Strategy, Horror, Co-op
Price: $49.99

Gather a few of your gaming friends and sit down for a game that never plays the same way twice. Betrayal at House on the Hill has a lot of parts and can be quite daunting for those playing it the first time, but once they get the hang of it there's a lot of fun to be had. The game was created by Bruce Glassco and the first edition won the Gamers Choice Award at the Origins Game Fair in 2004. It consists of twelve different explorers for the players to control, all with unique statistics in Speed, Might, Sanity, and Knowledge. Those explorers are tasked with exploring an old house. The ground floor and upper level are open to the players at the onset of the game, with the basement becoming accessible through a variety of ways. There are a total of 44 total rooms possible in the house, laid out at random as rooms are explored. Most of the rooms have a special feature, either a condition for entering/leaving, an item hidden in the room, and event that is triggered upon discovery, or an ominous Omen.

Items are pretty self-explanatory. Most of them are there in order to help your character in combat or exploration. These are the primary way your character increases in power as the game goes on. Most of them can be given to other players, some are expended after a single use, and later on they can be stolen. Events are creepy things that happen upon entering a room. Sometimes they're good, increasing statistics are conferring items to the player, and sometimes they're bad, reducing statistics, trapping an explorer until they're able to free themselves, or otherwise impeding the players' progress. The real danger comes from the Omens. These are cards that on face value are generally very beneficial to the player; companions, powerful weapons, large stat boosts, and more. In small doses they're a good thing. Every time an Omen is drawn though the player who draws it must make a Haunt roll. The roll most be greater than the total number of Omens on the table, if it's not the game takes a dramatic turn; from cooperative exploration to, most often, murderous predation.


After an unsuccessful Haunt roll the players consult one of the included books, the Traitor's Tome, to determine the identity of the traitor. Depending on the room that was responsible for the Haunt, the Omen that was drawn in that room, and occasionally the Haunt revealer, one of fifty different scenarios is indicated to be that game's Haunt. Aside from two scenarios without a traitor, this mechanic will pit one of the players against the rest in a unique confrontation. The traitor consults the aforementioned Traitor's Tome while the forces of good get their instructions from Secrets of Survival. The best way to tackle this part of the game is to separate the two parties and go over the scenario and its dangers and conditions for victory before reconvening and continuing the game. It's important to remember that all of the information shared in one book may not have been included in the other, so be careful with what you say, you could be inadvertently sharing too much with your enemy.

For me this is where the game really shines. There are so many different Haunts that the game never feels stale. There are Haunts involving Voodoo, demon lords, dragons, lycanthropes, one inspired by The Picture of Dorian Gray and more. Some of the scenarios do have a bit of an issue with balance, they're either too easily won by the Survivors or the Traitor, but for the most part they're challenging fun for both sides. The only real complaint with this aspect of the game is that it can be a little jarring to stop the game for ten to fifteen minutes, read a new set of rules, form a strategy, and then get back to the game. Try to look at it as an opportunity for everyone to take a rest room break, freshen up a drink, get a snack, and get back to it.

As you can imagine, this type of game involves a lot of pieces. Aside from those already mentioned there are almost 150 tokens intended to represent any of the variety of beasties the Haunt might unleash on the world. It can be quite a task to sort through all of those tokens to find the ones you need for a specific Haunt. Another issue with the pieces are these tiny plastic clips intended to be used to track each players' statistics on the sides of their player card. The clips fit very loosely on the card and come dislodged if someone closes a door on the other side of the house too vigorously. We've used bobby pins in the past to accomplish the task that those clips fail so miserably at. Small paper clips would also do the job, and I've been intending to pick up a bag of tiny clothespins to try.

Conclusion: Once you can overcome the rather steep learning curve Betrayal at House on the Hill will provide you and your friends with hours of entertainment. Although it's not a game for neophyte gamers, casual players will get the hang of it after a game or two. The sheer number of options make even your practice sessions fun. Just find a substitute for some of the lesser quality pieces and avoid the headache of trying to remember if that last Hideous Shriek drove you insane or if you're still in the fight.

Rating: 8/10

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Forbidden Island


Forbidden Island
Publisher: Gamewright (2012)
Players: 2-4
Play Time: Approximately 30 minutes
Genre: Board Game, Strategy, Co-op
Price: $17.99

Forbidden Island is another game from Matt Leacock, you might remember him from my previous review of Pandemic. It's another cooperative game, in which the players assume the roles of adventurers on an island, trying to track down four treasures. What could be so hard about that you might ask? The game is a race against the clock, the island is sinking and you must recover the treasures and escape the island before it sinks into an oceanic abyss.

Much like Pandemic the adventurers in Forbidden Island each have a special ability that helps you solve the puzzle that is the island. The different roles open up options for the players in movement and abilities, such as shoring up flooded island tiles essentially unflooding them. If a previously flooded tile is flooded again through a “Waters Rise” draw it is removed from play. There in lies the danger in the game. Mr. Leacock again creates multiple ways to lose the game, and only one way to win it. To win the game the players must collect all four treasures, congregate at Fools' Landing, the very appropriately landing pad for the heroes only means of escape from the island, and then one player must play one of three Helicopter Lift cards from the treasure deck.

Losing the game is much easier. There are four different ways to lose the game, all based around the flooding mechanic. The first and most obvious is if the water level reaches the dreaded skull and crossbones on the Water Meter. If a player is on an island tile that sinks, and there is no adjacent tile for them to escape to, they perish; thereby losing the game for the entire team. Leaving a man behind is not an option. If Fools' Landing sinks then your only method for escape sinks with it and the team loses. Finally if both of the tiles that grant access to any one of the treasures sinks the game is lost, returning home with three of the four treasures is not acceptable. No one will buy an incomplete set apparently!


With all that in mind the game play can be quite hectic. The first time several places that you need to win are flooded there's a mad scramble to save them before the next “Waters Rise” card. It's important during those times that the players really talk about what their next few steps should be. Any inefficiency in action can result in a quick reshuffle and restart. The most important thing to keep in mind, like in most cooperative games, is that you're there for everyone to have fun. One person ruling the table is not fun for everyone else. Sure, if you're teaching the game to new people you might have to be a little more visible in the decision making process, but after one game everyone will understand the rules and complexities enough that they can and should speak their minds.

When all the planning comes together and you finally escape the Forbidden Island I find you're almost always tempted to set up another game. I'm proud to say that I know this from experience, as this is a Matt Leacock creation that hasn't stymied me at every turn, unlike my nemesis Pandemic. That's when another game feature shines. Not only can you make the game harder by starting the water level at a more advanced state, the game board changes every time you play. That easy first game you played, with the treasures all clustered around Fools' Landing, it's but a memory as you're next game features a treacherous hike from important place to place. It's the variety in the game place that will keep me coming back for more.

Conclusion: Forbidden Island is a great cooperative game, so if playing with friends instead of against them is your thing then this is a great place to get your feet wet (ha ha). Between the variable difficulty and the multitude of configurations for the island there's a lot of replay value to be had here. This is a game well suited to a wide range of gamers, the inexperienced and the old experts, which makes it a good way to get a group of varying experience levels together and gaming.

Rating: 8/10

Tuesday, December 30, 2014

Pandemic


Pandemic
Publisher: ZMan Games (2012)
Players: 2-4
Play Time: Approximately 45 minutes
Genre: Board Game, Strategy, Co-op
Price: $39.99

Pandemic is the first of several games designed by Matt Leacock that readers will be seeing here. He seems to specialize in cooperative games, for those unfamiliar with the terminology those are games in which the players play against the game instead of against each other. I really enjoy cooperative games, sure trash-talking your friends can be fun but I have just as much fun hearing the different plans that everyone can come up with to tackle the same problem. I just seems to be a more social experience when everyone is working towards the same goal.

Commonly there are many ways to lose these types of games, and one way to win them. Pandemic is no exception. The players lose the game if the game board suffers through eight outbreaks, if you run out of disease cubes to place on the board, or if the players run out of cards to draw from the draw pile. That's right, even the draw pile isn't not your friend, instead of reshuffling and starting over, the players lose the game when the cards run out. It's a punishing mechanic that forces the players to do something meaningful with every turn, biding your time isn't an option.

It isn't the most punishing mechanic though, that honor is held by the outbreaks that occur in the game. Throughout the course of play infection cubes are placed on cities around the map, when those cities reach three cubes they become a ticking time bomb. If another cube would normally be placed on a thrice infected city that city suffers an outbreak, placing infection cubes on all cities connected to it. The worst case scenario is that an adjacent city reaches the outbreak point due to the initial outbreak, throwing out even more infection cubes (thankfully a city can't outbreak twice as part of the same chain) and making a bad situation downright dismal.


“With so many paths to failure arrayed before the players how do the good guys win the game?” you ask. The players must discover cures for all four diseases on the board. It's important to remember that you DO NOT have to eradicate the diseases to win, you just need to discover the cures. Without keeping that tidbit in mind the players will find the game nigh impossible to win. Believe me, Pandemic doesn't need any help, it's difficult enough as it is.

There are a lot of things to remember during the course of a game. Reference cards are provided to serve as reminders of all of the different things that are possible during a player's turn. Pay close attention to the movement rules regarding the use of city cards for transportation and the sharing knowledge mechanic afforded the players. Getting either of those things wrong drastically changes the way the game plays and you'll be kicking yourself when you realize that your easy victory came from a misapplication of the rules.

Conclusion: Pandemic is an insanely challenging game. I wouldn't recommend it for neophyte gamers unless there is someone very experienced around to help guide everyone through a couple of games. In the same vein, it might not be the best game to wrap up a play session with, as there's a better than decent chance you'll end the game humbled in defeat, staring sullenly at your implacable foe; an unfeeling, remorseless collection of cardboard and plastic. With all that being said; when you do manage to defeat this evil, brought into our world by Matt Leacock, you'll feel an amazing sense of accomplishment...or so I've heard.

Rating: 7.75/10