Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Gotham: Season 1, Episode 12


Gotham
Episode Title: “What the Little Bird Told Him”
Channel: Fox
Director: Eagle Egilsson
Writer: Ben Edlund
Genre: Crime, Drama, Thriller
Runtime: 42 min
Rated: TV-14
Original Air Date: January 19, 2015

The one thing this episode got right was the focus. Instead of trying to weave three or four stories into one block of time the majority of the episode focused on two story lines. That is of course if you discount the scene involving Barbara returning home to her parents. That probably should have been left off completely, as Barbara has become so unlikable I think it would be best if the audience were allowed to forget about her for a while. This would allow the writers to figure out some way to make her more tolerable. Her painfully awkward reunion with her parents and their level of strangeness only served to cause a stutter in the narrative, instead of making me care at all about them.

Early on the audience is led to believe that Fish's plan is finally coming to fruition. She's prepared to make her move and make herself the head of the crime families of Gotham. She has an agent in place that's trusted enough by her target to take him out with little to no suspicion from the Don. When Fish's plan is revealed to be forcing Falcone out of Gotham instead of eliminating him it feels like a huge let down. After all the vitriol she's spewed behind his back she decides to offer him exile instead of death. It's just not the kind of resolution I can believe coming from Fish. After all of her machinations she'd never leave an enemy alive and able to exact revenge. When Falcone is informed of the plan by The Penguin he takes the fight to Fish and demonstrates first hand the weakness in Fish's plan, as he does personally what she was so unwilling to do by proxy. The threat posed by Liza is ended by the Don himself, although inexplicably he allows Fish to live. That decision seems to have been made by the writers simply to keep Jada Pinkett-Smith around for a while longer.

The excitement from last week over the prospect of a recurring villain in the character of Jack Gruber dissipated quickly this week. Gruber is out for revenge against the man he believes sold him out years ago, Don Maroni. His methods are so haphazard that after his initial strike it became apparent that he was no kind of threat. He killed people he didn't need to, and left alive those that were supposedly his targets. To make matters worse he is ultimately thwarted by a glass of water. While humorous, there could be no more ignoble an end than that for a villain. Since the Electrocutioner had been developed far more than any other villain thus far, barring the crime families, I had expected a far greater pay off. This doesn't even take into account the 'investigation' that surrounded his case; it wasn't so much an investigation as a series of coincidences that filled in all the blanks. It felt like very lazy writing.

Bruce and Alfred were missing in action again, which I think is a good thing. When they do appear again it may be with significant growth in their relationship and Bruce's skills, without forcing five minute tidbits into already overflowing episodes. Also the writers' fascination with reminding everyone who Nygma will become is trying my patience. It's time to allow him to fade into the background until there's something worthwhile for him to do.

Conclusion: The two stories covered in “What the Little Bird Told Him” and their resolutions did not leave behind a feeling of satisfaction. Supposedly ruthless people making boneheaded decisions is not good drama, it's just bad writing. While the primary focus of the episode on two stories was a good plan; the peripheral events detracted from what was already a weak episode.

Rating: 6/10

No comments:

Post a Comment